Skip to content
EDITORIAL

Dead-end defense?

TAnd what did the defense bring? Old videos of the late Sen. Miriam Defensor-Santiago and the late Chief Justice Renato Corona.

Dead-end defense?
Text size

Has Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense team run out of people to call? On Thursday, even the dead were resurrected for her impeachment trial.

After a brief break for the 49th ASEAN Summit, the senators donned their red robes again for Day 44 of Duterte’s impeachment trial. And what did the defense bring?

Old videos of former Sen. Miriam Defensor-Santiago and the late Chief Justice Renato Corona.

Defense lawyer Mark Vinluan presented clips from Corona’s 2012 impeachment trial, drawing parallels between the withdrawal of impeachment charges then against Corona and now against Duterte.

But what exactly did digging up the dead prove in Duterte’s case? Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo questioned the relevance of the videos, saying it was like “watching a movie.”

“Let’s let the dead rest. That was a different case. This is a different case. This is a different set of senators. It’s also a different time. I really do not understand. Why are we watching this?” he said.

Senator-judge Panfilo Lacson agreed, pointing out that Santiago’s opinion was hers alone, not the position of all the 24 senator-judges then.

Lacson had a point.

Also read Superficial bishops

Santiago was a respected legal mind. Corona was once the country’s highest-ranking magistrate. But neither can testify on Duterte’s finances or answer the allegations against her. The dead cannot be cross-examined.

The defense may have been trying to establish a procedural parallel, particularly over the prosecution’s withdrawal of impeachment articles. That is a legitimate argument to raise.

But of all the cases to revisit, why choose one that ended in a conviction? Because Corona was convicted.

In May 2012, the Senate voted 20-3 to remove Corona from office over his failure to properly disclose assets in his Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth.

Tulfo reminded Duterte’s lawyers of that inconvenient truth.

Even impeachment court presiding officer Sen. Francis Escudero warned that presenting Corona’s statements was at the defense’s own peril.

Quite a choice of a precedent for someone fighting to keep her office.

So what exactly was the defense trying to establish? That Duterte, like Corona, is being politically persecuted? That withdrawing charges is unfair? Or that the Senate should revisit how impeachment proceedings are handled?

Senator Alan Peter Cayetano defended the presentation, arguing that Duterte’s lawyers deserve the same latitude that was given to the prosecutors.

He also raised the concern that withdrawing the charges denied the defense the opportunity to rebut allegations already discussed in court. Fair enough.

But a procedural argument is not an explanation of finances. The remaining impeachment charge centers on allegations of Duterte’s unexplained wealth and prohibited business interests.

The prosecution has alleged at least P817.87 million in unexplained wealth between 2022 and 2025.

Reports involving approximately P4.4 billion in financial transactions linked to Duterte and her husband have also figured in the proceedings, although reported transactions do not automatically establish wrongdoing.

The defense disputes the allegations, and the burden of proof remains with the prosecution. These are serious questions requiring financial records, explanations and evidence. Not a trip down impeachment memory lane.

Duterte’s lawyers have every right to challenge the calculations, question witnesses and present documents supporting their defense.

And the public deserves to hear those answers.

But if the defense wants to borrow Corona’s arguments, it should remember that it cannot choose which part of his story to retell. The former chief justice had also claimed political persecution. Still, he was convicted.

Does the defense really want Sara Duterte to end up like Corona?

Your sign today

Pick your Chinese zodiac sign for a daily forecast by Master Hanz Cua.