Senator-judges
Lawmakers, who hold partisan loyalties and political interests, act as both accusers in the House and jurors in the Senate.
The problem with some senator-judges is that they don’t respect the impeachment process, yet get upset when they feel like they are being disrespected. This is outright hypocrisy, plain and simple. To be honest, they are among the major reasons why the proceedings are losing their credibility.
Instead of maintaining their judicial neutrality or, at the very least, showing some semblance of it, just like their predecessors in previous impeachment trials, they behave like petulant children, throwing tantrums here and there just because they couldn’t get what they want.
In fact, they act like fiery advocates and overly outspoken interrogators rather than neutral adjudicators. They castigate witnesses, use intimidating lines of questioning and show manifest bias despite their supposed sworn duty to uphold the rules.
Since they lack proper legal discernment, their questioning often devolves into grandstanding, rescuing one side and badgering witnesses rather than clarifying facts. They are quick to cite witnesses in contempt or declare certain documents inadmissible or mere scraps of paper simply because they are not favorable to the agenda they’re pushing for.
And because they are elected politicians rather than regular court justices, they prioritize political alliances, public scrutiny and partisan leanings more than anything else. They exhibit blatant biases and have no qualms about disregarding proper decorum and compliance with the rules.
Certainly, political biases are a common feature of impeachment proceedings and are therefore expected. After all, lawmakers, who hold partisan loyalties and political interests, act as both accusers in the House and jurors in the Senate.
What makes the case of the present senator-judges astonishingly despicable, though, is that they have abandoned the constitutional accountability mechanism attached to impeachment, treating it purely as an avenue for political opportunism. This means their decision will simply be about political alignments instead of being based on legal and evidentiary standards.
Then, there’s this issue of incompetence. Many of them lack the analytical thinking needed to judiciously examine testimonies, legal arguments and documentary evidence. Due to their lack of familiarity with court procedures, they just don’t know what to do.
Unfortunately, there is no external legal mechanism to force a biased or legally inept senator to recuse themselves, leaving inhibition largely to the senator’s own conscience, which, by the way, he sorely lacks.







