Sovereignty over short-lived appeasement
The practicality of the Philippine policy toward China depends on balancing national sovereignty in the West Philippine Sea against deep, high stakes economic integration with Beijing.

(The Auditor congratulates CoA Chair Gamaliel Asis Cordoba on his elevation to Associate Justice of the Supreme Court)
That sovereignty is preferable to short-lived appeasement was amply demonstrated in the historic “debate” in Parañaque City when a heated public exchange occurred between Philippine Coast Guard and Spokesperson Commodore Jay Tarriela and Chinese academic Dr. Zhang Zhihara.
Here’s the encounter:
Dr. Zhang Zhihara fired first: “Second Thomas Shoal, Chinese territory, for more than 27 years.”
Rear Admiral Jay Tarriela fired back: “China does not have any territorial jurisdiction whatsoever in Second Thomas Shoal.”
Tarriela argued that Second Thomas Shoal is 125 nautical miles from the Philippines, while it is 600 nautical miles from China.
Pre-Summit diplomatic outreach
Earlier in November, Foreign Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro and Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi held talks aimed at managing the tension and keeping diplomatic channels open ahead of President Ferdinand Marcos Jr.’s trip to China for the APEC meetings.
The practicality of Philippine policy
The practicality of the Philippine policy toward China depends on balancing national sovereignty in the West Philippine Sea against deep, high stakes economic integration with Beijing.
Arguments that a hardline or decoupling policy is impractical
1. Heavy Trade and Supply Chain Reliance: China is the Philippines’ top trading partner, its third largest export market, and its primary source of imports. Critics and business groups warn that sudden economic friction or full decoupling could trigger higher costs for consumers and disrupt access to affordable goods like technology, electric vehicles, and industrial equipment.
2. Energy and Infrastructure Vulnerabilities: Analysts point out that a significant portion — roughly 40 percent — of the Philippines’ refined fuel imports originate from China, leaving the domestic energy supply exposed to potential retaliatory freezes. Additionally, Chinese entities hold a major stake in critical utilities like the National Grid Corporation of the Philippines.
3. Economic Retaliatory Risks: Reports highlight potential economic counter-measures, such as restrictions on Filipino workers in Hong Kong and Macau, curbs on agricultural/fertilizer exports, and a drop in Chinese tourists, that could hurt local livelihoods if tensions escalate unchecked.
Arguments that accommodating policy is impractical or dangerous
1. Erosion of National Sovereignty: Civil society and security advocates argue that conceding maritime rights or downplaying territorial incursions in the West Philippine Sea compromises the country’s long-term independence and maritime wealth.
2. Asymmetric Dependency: Proponents of a firmer stance contend that uncritical economic dependence creates political leverage for Beijing, enabling China to constrain independent Philippine policy decisions and security alliances.
3. The Path of Diversification: Rather than choosing between total subjugation and economic suicide, groups like Democracy Watch argue that the practical path is strengthening domestic manufacturding, building self-reliant infrastructure, and diversifying trade partnerships (such as through deeper ties with Japan, the US and ASEAN neighbors) rather than sacrificing sovereignty for short-term appeasement.
Key developments from the 29th ASEAN-China Summit
The Maritime Dispute in the West Philippine Sea and South China Sea were directly addressed during the 29th ASEAN-China Summit in Manila co-chaired by President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. and Chinese Premier Li Qiang.
Call for action over words
Opening the summit, President Marcos stressed that commitments to international law, the 1982 UNCLOS, and peaceful dispute settlements “must be reflected in our actions” through self-restraint and mutual respect.
China’s response
Premier Li Qiang emphasized regional stability, mutual trust, and strong economic momentum, citing over $1 trillion in bilateral trade rather than directly addressing specific maritime incidents in his public remarks.
Email: arturobesana2@gmail.com






