Skip to content
NATION

SC clears ex-Western Visayas police chief

ASSOCIATE Justice Ramon Paul Hernando

ASSOCIATE Justice Ramon Paul Hernando

Text size

The Supreme Court (SC) has nullified the dismissal of retired police general Bernardo Diaz, ruling that executive and police oversight bodies violated his right to due process when they removed him from the service over alleged links to illegal drugs during the Duterte administration.

In a ruling dated 12 August penned by Associate Justice Ramon Paul Hernando, the SC First Division reversed the dismissal orders issued by the Office of the President (OP) and the National Police Commission (Napolcom) against Diaz, former director of the Police Regional Office 6 (Western Visayas).

“All told, the totality of circumstances show that the proceedings before the Napolcom and the issuance by the OP of its Decision and Resolution were tainted with irregularities and disregarded petitioner’s right to due process and rules of procedure,” the High Court stated.

The administrative case stemmed from a July 2016 speech by then-President Rodrigo Duterte during the Philippine Air Force anniversary, when he publicly named Diaz as one of several Philippine National Police (PNP) generals allegedly serving as protectors of illegal drug syndicates.

Following Duterte’s accusation, Napolcom conducted administrative proceedings, found Diaz liable for grave neglect of duty and recommended his removal from the police force.

The Office of the President subsequently adopted the recommendation, ordering Diaz’s dismissal and later denying his appeal through a separate resolution.

Diaz elevated the case to the Supreme Court, arguing that the administrative investigation and his subsequent dismissal failed to observe established legal procedures. The SC First Division ultimately upheld his challenge and cleared him of administrative liability.

The High Court said the Napolcom complaint against Diaz was based on Duterte’s public statements, which could not be considered a verbal complaint under the applicable rules. These rules require a complaint-affidavit accompanied by supporting documents.

Also read DoH chief urges global unity vs child abuse

The special order that initiated the investigation also contained only a general statement that Diaz was among police officers allegedly involved in illegal drug activities, without specifying the material allegations of the offense committed, the SC said.

The court further observed that the pre-charge investigation to determine probable cause against Diaz appeared to have been reduced to a “mere formality” because an earlier investigation had already been conducted.

It also found no circumstances that would justify treating the proceedings as a motu proprio investigation.

Napolcom’s failure to observe fairness in handling the case violated Diaz’s right to due process, the SC ruled.

“The unfairness manifested in Napolcom’s disregard of its own rules of procedure in the commencement of an administrative complaint and the conduct of investigations,” it added.

The SC also faulted the Office of the President for disregarding evidence presented by Diaz, which it dismissed as lacking probative value or being self-serving.

The court said Napolcom and the OP failed to genuinely consider the progress reports submitted by Diaz, which formed the core of his defense against allegations that he had failed to conduct anti-drug operations and arrest suspects.

Your sign today

Pick your Chinese zodiac sign for a daily forecast by Master Hanz Cua.