The Philippine pageant community has united in defense of national identity following controversial remarks made by Filipino-American male titleholders Brandon Espiritu and Jether Palomo that sparked widespread discussion online.

Among the first prominent voices to respond was beauty queen Gazini Ganados, who shared a powerful message emphasizing that being Filipino goes beyond ancestry or ethnicity. Posting an image of the Philippine flag on social media, the Filipino-Palestinian queen declared that no one has the authority to define another person’s Filipino identity.

“My love for the Philippines is not measured by blood quantum, but by the pride, respect, and service I give to my country,” Ganados wrote, a statement that quickly resonated with pageant fans and fellow titleholders.

Her post drew support from reigning Miss Universe Philippines 2026 Bea Millan-Windorski, who simply described Ganados as “A true Queen.”

The issue erupted after a now-deleted social media video showed several international male pageant titleholders being challenged to sing their respective national anthems. Instead of singing “Lupang Hinirang,” the Philippine representatives in the clip performed the United States national anthem, prompting questions from viewers.

The controversy intensified when screenshots surfaced showing exchanges in the comments section. In one response, Espiritu reportedly stated that the Philippines “wouldn’t have a chance on the national stage without us halfies,” a remark that many pageant supporters viewed as dismissive of Filipino-born contestants and titleholders.

The comments drew criticism not only from fans but also from fellow pageant winners.

Mister International 2025 Kirk Bondad, who is of Filipino and German heritage, publicly disagreed with the statement while calling for understanding and reflection.

“I would have approached the conversation differently,” Bondad said, adding that a single mistake should not permanently define a person’s character.

“We all say things we wish we had phrased differently. Once these situations become about punishment and pride, nobody really wins,” he added.

Bondad ended his message by reaffirming his gratitude to the country he represents.

“The Philippines has given me a sense of belonging, purpose, and some of the most meaningful experiences of my life, and I am eternally grateful for that,” he said.

Mr. Cosmo Philippines Enzo Bonoan also expressed disappointment over the remarks while maintaining his friendship with those involved. He stressed that accountability and compassion can exist at the same time.

“I’m not here to cancel anyone. But love that’s real tells the truth and the truth is those words were undoubtedly wrong, and they hurt people who deserve better,” Bonoan said.

He added that he hoped the controversy would become an opportunity for growth and learning.

As criticism mounted, both Espiritu and Palomo issued public apologies. Palomo acknowledged the impact of their comments and accepted responsibility for his role in the controversy.

“To everyone I hurt, offended, or disappointed, I am sincerely sorry,” he said. “This moment has pushed me to reflect, listen, and genuinely learn.”

While the debate began with a viral social media exchange, it has since evolved into a broader conversation about representation, identity, and what it truly means to wear the Philippine sash on the international stage.

For many in the pageant community, the issue is not about heritage, birthplace, or ethnicity. Rather, it is about respect for the country being represented and recognizing that Filipino pride cannot be measured solely by bloodline, but by commitment, service, and love for the nation.