Skip to content
BUSINESS

Brods on the bench

Brods on the bench
Text size

A seat on the Supreme Court is up for grabs. Its former occupant moved up to Chief Justice on 6 November, leaving a vacancy that the Judicial and Bar Council (JBC) must fill from a list of applicants and nominees. The deadline for submitting applications is 28 December. The JBC will then screen the candidates and send a shortlist to the President, who will make the final choice.

It is a coveted seat, and for good reason. A Supreme Court justice helps shape rulings that affect the lives and rights of every Filipino. It is hardly surprising, therefore, that influential circles are taking an interest in who will get to wear the robe.

Nosy Tarsee, for one, has been hearing whispers about a law fraternity at the Ateneo. Founded in 1964, the brotherhood takes pride in its bar topnotchers and counts prominent members in the legal profession. It has also had two of its own on the Supreme Court. One has since retired, while the other has moved up to lead the Court.

Also read Brutal reality

Now comes the name being floated.

He is 66, a lawyer who once served as a top aide to a former president but has never sat on the bench. He graduated from the same law school and joined the same brotherhood in 1981. One of his close friends from those school days is already a member of the High Court.

There is, however, a practical consideration. At 66, he would have only four years before reaching themandatory retirement age of 70. Would he want a Supreme Court appointment with such a short runway? That is a question only he can answer.

The whispers suggest that influential Ateneo circles are backing him, potentially giving the brotherhood another entry in the race. If he makes the shortlist, and if the President chooses him, the fraternity could once again have a brother on the bench.

Those are two big ifs. And they matter.

There is nothing inherently improper about friends recommending friends or alumni supporting a fellow alumnus. But when the prize is a seat on the country’s highest court, the public is entitled to ask whether personal ties are being given more weight than judicial merit.

The President did not serve with the man in question, but that does not automatically rule him out. This administration has drawn appointees from different political camps. The field includes candidates with judicial experience, an important qualification to weigh against the credentials of someone who has never been a judge.

So let us wait for 28 December. When the names are finally in, take a closer look at the list. Count the fraternity brothers.

And ask whether the race is about the best person for the bench — or who has the best connections to mount it.

Your sign today

Pick your Chinese zodiac sign for a daily forecast by Master Hanz Cua.