Chiz warns lawyers about public posts



The prosecution treats this as a scandal — which it is not — since it is the system working as designed.

Hindi napigilan ni Lead Defense Counsel Sheila Sison na punahin ang umano'y "nakababahalang" post ni Private Prosecutor…

A prosecutor’s social media post about a heated courtroom exchange has prompted the Senate impeachment court to prepare…

Medyo nag-init ang Senate impeachment court sa sagutan nina private prosecutor Atty. Lorna Kapunan at defense counsel…

Impeachment court presiding officer Senator Francis “Chiz” Escudero joked that private prosecutor Atty. Lorna Kapunan…
A prosecutor’s social media post about a heated courtroom exchange has prompted the Senate impeachment court to prepare a ruling on whether lawyers involved in Vice President Sara Duterte’s trial have crossed the line on their public commentary.
Presiding Officer Senator Francis “Chiz” Escudero said on Wednesday he was drafting a ruling, warning, and order on possible violations of Rule 18 after defense lead counsel Sheila Sison challenged a Facebook post by private prosecutor Amando Virgilio Ligutan.
Sison said Ligutan’s public post, which stated that “misleading questions are not allowed even in cross-examination,” appeared to refer to an earlier exchange between private prosecutor Lorna Kapunan and defense counsel Kristine Ferrer.
She said the post mischaracterized Ferrer’s position and was inappropriate because it was made while the impeachment court was in session.
“I really just find it in bad taste to do this at this time,” Sison told the court.
“An impeachment court is also a court of decorum,” she said, arguing that lawyers on opposing sides were members of the bar and officers of the court who owed each other respect.
Earlier, Kapunan had objected to Ferrer’s line of questioning, saying that not every question could be posed that way before telling the court: “There are limits to cross-examination. Misleading questions are not allowed on cross.”
Ferrer replied: “They are allowed.”
Sison said Ferrer was referring to leading questions, which are allowed during cross-examination, and she was not endorsing misleading questions.
“Yet we have a private prosecutor immediately taking to social media and posting this, implying something against the defense counsel,” Sison said.
Under Rule 18 of the Senate impeachment rules, the presiding officer, senators, prosecutors, the respondent, their respective counsel and witnesses are barred from publicly commenting on the merits of a pending impeachment case.
Escudero said the court had been tracking the public statements made by the lawyers and warned that the issue went beyond Ligutan’s post.
“I asked the clerk of court to monitor the public statements of the counsels of the parties this past week,” Escudero said.
He said he had previously reminded both sides that they could appoint spokespersons who were not members of the prosecution or defense teams to handle their public statements.
He said the court was preparing a ruling and warning on the matter and would hear Ligutan before deciding on it on Monday.