Who is the new Lady Whistledown?
Dearest gentle reader, pray tell, are you perhaps reeling with shock that plagues the rest of the ton?
Text size
Dearest gentle reader, pray tell, are you perhaps reeling with shock that plagues the rest of the ton?
As Lady Whistledown, Penelope gained the attention of Queen Charlotte. The queen's expectations clashed with Penelope's growth and new perspective on gossip.
Photo courtesy of Netflix.
Sophie and Benedict Bridgerton's love story was the focus of Season 4.
Photo courtesy of Netflix.
The society papers were the heart of the mystery and intrigue that Bridgerton gave its viewers in its first season.
Photo courtesy of Netflix.
Eloise Bridgerton, Brimsley, and Lady Danbury are some of the hottest suspects of the internets' growing speculations.
Composite photo, courtesy of Netflix.
The Season 4 finale of Bridgerton has delivered a twist so scandalous, so deliciously audacious, that even the most seasoned members of the ton are clutching their pearls. Penelope Bridgerton has retired her quill. And yet Lady Whistledown lives on.
Yes, you read that correctly.
In Episode 6, Penelope announces her retirement at Cressida Cowper’s first ball as Lady Penwood, distributing pamphlets in true Whistledown fashion. Speaking to Queen Charlotte, she confesses:
“Like you, I will always believe in the power of gossip. But since I have become known publicly, there has been a change. The power I hold over the ton is too great.”
Penelope acknowledges that marriage into the Bridgerton family has altered her standing and her power. The anonymity that once shielded her has vanished. The column, once a weapon for the voiceless, has become something heavier, something fraught with consequence.
“I’m no longer a wallflower, an outsider. I am a Bridgerton. I’m privileged to visit the queen. Whistledown takes up a space which makes it impossible to deliver good, true, fair gossip.”
With Queen Charlotte’s reluctant blessing, Penelope steps aside and turns her attention to novel-writing. A neat, poetic ending. Or so we thought.
As Benedict and Sophie’s wedding montage unfurls in the finale, a voice returns. Familiar, yet not. Still voiced by Julie Andrews, yet edged with something different.
The new Whistledown purrs:
“Are you perhaps feeling a little shock? You thought I was gone for good, but far too much transpires for this author to remain silent. It is assuredly a reunion rooted in care and love, though this time with a very different author. But for now, my new identity shall remain a secret. Dear reader, we are going to have so much fun.”
Fun? For whom, one wonders.
Showrunner Jess Brownell has been positively gleeful about the switch. Speaking to Tudum, she explained the motivation behind stepping away from Julia Quinn’s original blueprint.
“Penelope was Julia Quinn’s Whistledown, so we knew we couldn’t really play with that reveal for too long because people could just Google it. But now, we get to play with audience expectations.”
To Radio Times, she added that the series has “gone rogue”. And to Entertainment Weekly, she teased that clues will be planted over several seasons, with no reveal in Season 5.
In short, the mystery is intentional. And it is here to stay.
Though Andrews remains the voice, Brownell confirmed that she has subtly altered her performance to reflect a different personality and modus operandi. Observant fans immediately detected a slightly more regional tone, less aristocratic polish.
What does that mean?
A servant, perhaps. A working woman on the fringes of Mayfair. Or someone clever enough to disguise their class origins entirely.
Brownell hinted that the new Whistledown may be “a little bit messier” and is “really [swinging] for the fences.” Penelope, for all her missteps, believed she was giving voice to the voiceless. This successor, it seems, may not be so noble.
The internet, as ever, has opinions.
Some fans are convinced it must be Eloise, long fascinated by Whistledown and ever eager to prove a point. Others place their bets on Alice Mondrich, newly appointed as Queen Charlotte’s chief lady-in-waiting, now perfectly positioned to observe both palace and parlour intrigue.
Brimsley has been nominated, his “little eyes” everywhere, privy to everything. Even Lady Danbury’s temporary retirement has sparked whispers of a convenient cover.
And then there are those who insist Penelope herself may be orchestrating an elaborate ruse, staging her retirement to operate in peace.
Not all are pleased. A vocal faction of viewers expressed anger that the title was “taken away” from Penelope, arguing that her arc as Whistledown was central to the show’s identity. Others, however, revel in the return of mystery, insisting the cat-and-mouse tension was sorely missed after her public reveal in Season 3.
By revealing Penelope as Whistledown early and then publicly outing her, the series lost the thrill of secrecy. Brownell admitted as much, noting that once the ton knew her identity, “it’s lost a bit of its stakes now that the whole world knows who she is.”
Introducing a new Whistledown restores that delicious uncertainty. The ton is once again on edge. Anyone could be watching. Anyone could be writing.
And so, dear reader, we find ourselves precisely where we began in Season 1: suspicious of every glance, every whisper, every conveniently placed pamphlet.
Season 4 concluded on 26 February 2026, with eight episodes released in two parts, first on 29 January 29 and then on 26 February. A fifth season has already been confirmed, with further seasons in development and production reportedly set to begin in spring 2026. Release dates remain unannounced.
Until then, we are left with speculation, scandal, and a single, tantalising promise:
“Dear reader, we are going to have so much fun.”
One suspects she is correct.
