Leonen stresses human cost of disputes
Leonen also emphasized the importance of allowing time for deliberation, distinguishing between delay and the interval needed to understand a dispute from different perspectives.

Supreme Court Senior Associate Justice Marvic Leonen urged lawyers and arbitrators to look beyond legal technicalities and consider the human consequences of disputes, stressing that conflicts involve strained relationships rather than merely cases or documents.
Speaking at the Philippine Dispute Resolution Center Inc.’s 30th-anniversary event, Leonen said disputes carry histories and personal circumstances that must be understood before they can be resolved.
“A conflict is not yet a case, and it is certainly not a file,” Leonen said. “It is a relationship under strain. Two parties expected something of each other, and the expectation failed. Every conflict, therefore, carries a history, and every history has a face.”
Drawing from his experience as the government’s chief peace negotiator with the Moro Islamic Liberation Front, Leonen recalled how disagreements over the structure of a Bangsamoro police force were resolved through compromise language that addressed the parties’ actual needs rather than their stated positions.
He said disputes could also expose circumstances and issues that parties had not anticipated when they entered into agreements, providing an opportunity to address gaps in their contracts.
Leonen also emphasized the importance of allowing time for deliberation, distinguishing between delay and the interval needed to understand a dispute from different perspectives.
“Delay is time taken from the parties. The interval is time given to understand them. A well-designed, expedited process removes the first and protects the second. Speed should shorten the delay, never the interval,” he said.
He distinguished judges, whose authority comes from the Constitution and the law, from arbitrators, whose authority rests on the parties’ consent. This allows parties to choose arbitrators with expertise relevant to their disputes, although an arbitral tribunal cannot exercise authority over those who did not agree to arbitration.
“An arbitral tribunal has no power over anyone who did not agree. It cannot compel compliance on its own,” Leonen said.
He cautioned that arbitration decisions could affect people beyond those directly involved, urging practitioners to remain mindful of those who ultimately bear the consequences.







