Customer is always right

Nosy Tarsee was perched on a branch, watching with his big eyes the development of a tale about a property developer — a small story with a big lesson.
A buyer once paid a reservation fee of P20,000 for a home being sold by a real estate giant.
The developer’s sales agent promised that a contract to sell would follow. Trusting that promise, the buyer paid another P110,000. In all, he handed over P130,000. But no contract ever came, and the agent stopped answering his calls.
So the buyer asked for his money back. The developer refused, arguing that its agent’s promise did not bind the company. The case then dragged through appeals for nearly 16 years.
“Hmm,” said Nosy Tarsee, blinking. “Whose promise was it, anyway?”
The Supreme Court said that when an agent speaks for a developer, the buyer relies on those words, and the company cannot simply walk away from them.
A reservation is a two-way deal: the buyer pays, and the developer issues the contract. When the developer fails to deliver, the buyer may cancel the transaction. The law calls this rescission, requiring both parties to return what they received.
The developer therefore had to refund the full P130,000, with six-percent annual interest from the filing of the complaint.
The Court did correct the lower tribunals on one point. The law on advertisements covers mass media, including newspapers, radio, television, leaflets and circulars. A private promise made to a single buyer does not qualify as an advertisement.
Still, the buyer won. The Civil Code protects those shortchanged by promises left unfulfilled.
Then came the kicker.
The High Tribunal said a big company could have easily settled such a small claim. Instead, it allowed the case to drag on, even after three tribunals had ruled against it.
For that delay, the Court imposed P260,000 in exemplary damages — twice the refund. The entire award would also earn six-percent annual interest from finality of judgment until fully paid.
A developer that acts fraudulently or disregards sound business practice may also lose its registration and license to sell, the Court said.
“So that’s the moral of the story,” said Nosy Tarsee, turning his head all the way around. “Issue the contract you promised. Teach your agents to tell the truth. And when you lose, pay up quickly.”
A small claim by an ordinary buyer is still a debt. Stall for years, and it only grows.





