Caloocan 2nd District Rep. Edgar Erice said that House Bill 9906, authored by House Speaker Bojie Dy is more of an "anti-contractor" measure than an anti-political dynasty law a bill banning government contractors and their relatives from running for congressional and party-list seats.

Also known as the "New Party-List System Act," many contractors no longer directly register contracts under their names. Often, their children or relatives are involved, although they still maintain control, Erice said in a radio interview.

Erice said he supports reforms that improve the political system, including restrictions that would prevent contractors and their relatives from participating in the party-list system if they have existing government contracts.

However, he criticized the anti-political dynasty bill previously approved by the House of Representatives, describing it as weak and ineffective.

He expressed doubts that the House and Senate versions of the anti-political dynasty bill could be reconciled during bicameral deliberations because of significant differences between the two proposals.

Erice said the Senate version imposes stricter restrictions by limiting members of the same family from simultaneously holding certain national and local elective positions, including congressional posts.

Asked whether House Bill 9906 still contains anti-political dynasty provisions, Erice said the measure appears focused primarily on contractors and business interests.

He warned that provisions disqualifying relatives of contractors from seeking public office could be considered arbitrary if not properly defined.

"The Constitution's framers were clear that any anti-political dynasty law should not be arbitrary," Erice said.