Two women who share the Miss Earth stage, Karen Ibasco (Miss Earth 2017) and Joy Barcoma (Miss Philippines Earth 2025), recently exchanged perspectives online after Ibasco offered her thoughts on the importance of using public platforms wisely — a statement that sparked a heartfelt response from Barcoma.

Karen Ibasco on Wisdom, Timing, and Respect

In a recent social media discussion, Ibasco shared her insights on how beauty queens should approach public speaking, especially in competitive settings like international pageants.

“You can’t answer when you’re not asked, because sometimes it can portray that you’re arrogant or rude even though you’re not,” Ibasco explained.

“It’s important to only speak when you’re asked. You need to understand how to use the platform wisely. Social media is good to be used by everyone appropriately… The stage is used for competition, and there’s airtime in every competition. Every candidate is only given a few seconds for the Q&A, but if you overdo that, the organization has to pay more because of the airtime.”

Known for her eloquence and intellect, the 2017 Miss Earth titleholder — who is also a physicist and climate advocate — appeared to be commenting on professionalism, time discipline, and decorum in pageantry. Her message highlighted how contestants must balance passion with precision when using their voices onstage.

Joy Barcoma Responds with Conviction

Shortly after, Joy Barcoma, who represented the Philippines in the Miss Earth 2025 competition, responded with grace and self-assurance. Her statement, which quickly resonated with fans, offered a different perspective — one rooted in purpose and authenticity.

“Thank you for this, Ms. Karen!” Barcoma began. “But given a chance to do it again, I’ll never change what I’ve done. The Earth needs to hear what’s happening in the Philippines — especially these tragedies that are repercussions of climate change and environmental abuse.”

Barcoma’s answer referred to her impassioned speech during the Miss Earth competition, where she exceeded her allotted time to discuss the devastating environmental challenges affecting the Philippines.

“Still, I won’t question the decision of the organization,” she continued. “I wasn’t who they wanted for the crown, and that’s okay.”

Her response, though direct, was marked by humility and sincerity — qualities that have defined her throughout her journey as a Miss Earth advocate.

Two Voices, One Advocacy

While their exchange drew attention across pageant circles, both Ibasco and Barcoma ultimately underscored the same message — that the Miss Earth platform exists to amplify voices for the planet, but that expression must also come with respect for the stage’s structure and rules.

Ibasco’s perspective highlighted discipline and professionalism, reminding candidates that effective communication includes knowing when and how to speak. Barcoma, meanwhile, emphasized authentic advocacy — that when the cause is urgent and the message is vital, passion can sometimes transcend formality.

Their dialogue represents two generations of Earth queens united by one purpose: to use their voices for environmental awareness while navigating the evolving dynamics of pageantry in the age of social media.

A Healthy Exchange in the Spirit of Miss Earth

Rather than conflict, fans and observers saw the exchange as a powerful reflection of how pageant queens continue to redefine what it means to lead. Both women approached the conversation with intelligence and respect, offering the public a rare glimpse of how queens can differ in opinion yet remain aligned in purpose.

In a digital era where every word is magnified, their discussion serves as a reminder that empowerment isn’t about who speaks the loudest — it’s about speaking with meaning, integrity, and heart.