Skip to content
SPORTS

Why CPR and defibrillators must be mandatory

Why CPR and defibrillators must be mandatory
Text size

Another life taken, another video, and another question we should be asking loudly.

Former Philippine Basketball Association star PJ Simon, 46, reportedly had difficulty breathing while playing in a 40-and-above basketball tournament in Davao City on Friday. He collapsed and was subsequently brought to a local hospital, where attempts to revive him were unsuccessful.

The footage is painful to watch. Simon was seen being fanned by bystanders on the team bench before he was carried by fellow players to an ambulance. Reports noted the apparent absence of an immediate medical response in the circulating footage, with no clearly visible medical personnel, ambulance or attempt at CPR.

Also read Runners set for Rock ‘N’ Roll celebration

His cause of death has not been confirmed. But consider the distinction that matters. A heart attack is no one’s fault. It can strike a fit 46-year-old on a bench in the middle of a game. His death is another matter. The first is a medical event. The second may well be the consequence of what was, or was not, done in the minutes that followed. Fanning a collapsed man is not treatment, and every minute without CPR and a defibrillator sharply cuts the chance of survival.

We have been here before. When 19-year-old Rene Baterbonia drowned during an Ateneo team-building activity in Aurora, the country was rightly enraged. His mother said the group had a medic only for first aid and no rescuer. Preparedness is not optional when lives are at stake. If the footage tells the whole story, a man collapsed in front of a crowd and no one was equipped to try to save him. That deserves the same scrutiny.

As a lawyer, I ask who owed a duty and whether it was breached. Philippine law has no single “sports injury” statute. Liability is built from general rules.

Duty of care in sports is governed by Article 2176 of the Civil Code, which obliges anyone who causes damage through fault or negligence to pay for it, and by Article 1173, which sets the diligence of a good father of a family. Sports event organizers fall under this standard. The Supreme Court has applied it to organizers before. In Abrogar v Cosmos Bottling and Intergames, the Court held that the organizer’s negligence was the proximate cause of a marathon participant’s death. It also ruled that the participant’s waiver could not bar recovery for an unappreciated, non-ordinary risk of death. Registration fees may create a contract as well, so failing to provide agreed safety measures can be a breach. Employers and organizers can also answer for the negligence of the staff and volunteers they engage.

The law does not ask who caused the heart attack. Nobody did. It asks whether a failure to prepare or respond turned a survivable emergency into a death. Negligence need not cause the underlying condition. It only has to be the proximate cause of the death.

Also read Hefty rewards await PUSO Games winners

Article 365 of the Revised Penal Code punishes reckless imprudence, which means doing or failing to do an act with inexcusable lack of precaution, considering the circumstances. Where death results, the charge is reckless imprudence resulting in homicide. The penalty generally does not exceed six years, and the offense is bailable as of right.

A prosecutor or plaintiff would have to show that timely CPR and defibrillation would probably have saved him. That takes medical evidence, starting with a confirmed cause of death. If that evidence comes, then in my view his death was most probably preventable, and the people who organized and ran the event must answer for it. Fellow players, who acted as best they knew how, should not be blamed.

There is a real gap. Our laws train children but do not equip events. RA 10871 requires basic education students to undergo basic life support training. Yet, the Philippine Heart Association is still urging Congress to pass an AED law to deploy defibrillators in strategic public places. Doctors have also pushed for a Good Samaritan law because many people fear being sued if they help. As far as I can tell, that protection is still only proposed. Without clear rules, we rely on after-the-fact negligence suits, and those come too late for the person on the floor.

We should require every organized event — from fun run to marathon, Hyrox to barangay league — must have trained medical personnel, an ambulance on standby and a working AED, as a permit condition.

Every club, team and league must have a CPR- and AED-certified person at every activity, including training and team-building.

Coaches, referees, marshals and organizers must hold basic life support certification.

Written emergency plans must be rehearsed, and organizers who skip them should be accountable.

Congress should pass an AED law and a Good Samaritan law, so those who step in are protected.

Hands-only CPR can be learned in a few hours, for less than the cost of a pair of racing shoes. Whether you run, lift, hoop or cheer, learn it and insist that your clubs do the same.

PJ Simon gave Philippine basketball years of joy. The least we owe him is that the next person who goes down on the sideline is met with trained hands, not a hand fan.

Your sign today

Pick your Chinese zodiac sign for a daily forecast by Master Hanz Cua.