Of the 37, five were listed in the ARs of the Department of Education (DepEd), which Vice President Sara Duterte concurrently headed from June 2022 to June 2024.
Assistant National Statistician Marizza Grande told private prosecutor Mae Divinagracia that the name Marlin Sunga corresponded to a death certificate of an infant who had been dead 61 years at the time she allegedly received confidential funds as stated on the AR.
Some of the supposed OVP recipients whose names matched those on death certificates included Fortunato Salig, who allegedly received P200,000; Emilio Sagan, who got P70,000; and Rodolfo Traya, who was given P120,000. They allegedly received the confidential funds in 2023, but the PSA verification showed that they died in June 2011, July 2015 and May 2021, respectively.
Overall, 1,685 names yielded no records of live birth, marriage, or death in the PSA database.
The 1,685 is equivalent to 63 percent of the total 2,669 names submitted by the House committee on good government and public accountability in November 2024 to the PSA for verification.
Senator-Judge Joel Villanueva asked Grande whether she found the 63 percent unregistered records found in the OVP and DepEd records as “unusual,” to which the witness answered in the affirmative, considering that the rate of non-matching records typically ranges between seven and eight percent, with some cases reaching up to 30 to 40 percent.
Grande also deemed such a high percentage of unregistered individuals “rare.”
The PSA records also showed that a Miko Alquizar was only one year old when he supposedly received confidential funds as alleged in the ARs. His birth certificate stated that he was born on 11 June 2022.
Another alleged recipient was named Beatrice Cuenca, who was born on 7 January 2022 and supposedly signed an AR on 14 March 2023.
“In your opinion, Ms. Grande, what kind of information could one-year-old Beatrice Cuenca possibly provide to the OVP or DepEd?” Divinagracia asked.
“[My testimony is] based only on [PSA] records so I cannot speculate,” Grande responded.
Presiding officer Sen. Chiz Escudero chimed in, “Would you know if it’s the same Beatrice Cuenca that signed that document? Would you be in a position to answer?” to which Grande replied, “No, sir.”
Grande was the sixth witness to take the stand for Article I, which centers on Vice President Sara Duterte’s alleged misuse of her confidential funds in the OVP and the DepEd, which received P500 million and P112.5 million, respectively.
Prosecutors have accused Duterte of embezzling the funds, alleging that the ARs provided by her two offices were fabricated, as they mostly bore “fictitious names” to justify the spending.
In total, there were 20 minors in the OVP list of payees and five minors in the DepEd’s.
Grande supervised the review of the civil registry records of the individuals listed as payees of the OVP and DepEd.
Out of 1,992 payees of the OVP’s confidential funds, 1,287 had no records of birth, marriage, or death, according to Grande.