Wednesday, 8 July 2026
Nasdaq -1.16%
Subscribe NowSupport Us

Daily TribuneDaily Tribune

Daily TribuneDaily Tribune
Subscribe
Wednesday, 8 July 2026
Nasdaq -1.16%
  • News
  • Page Three
  • Commentary
  • Business
  • Life
  • Show
  • Tech Talks
  • Sports
  • Global Goals
  • Dyaryo Tirada
Partner feature
Daily Tribune

The Philippines' leading digital newspaper.

News
  • Headlines
  • Metro
  • Nation
  • World
Commentary
  • Opinion
  • Editorial
  • Scuttlebutt
Business
  • Shipping
  • Portraits
  • Pep
  • Business Advisories
Life
  • Show
  • Food & Drink
  • Getaways
  • Arts & Culture
  • Social Set
  • Spaces
  • Fashion & Beauty
  • The Edit
  • Top Form
  • Next Gen
  • Sacred Space
  • Project Larawan
  • Snaps
Sports
  • Hoops
  • Volley
  • Golf
  • Goal
  • Boxing
  • Tennis
  • Esports
  • Blast

Company

  • About
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Privacy
  • Subscribe
  • Support Us

© 2026 Daily Tribune · tribune.net.ph · Powered by Quintype

PAGE THREE

Defense stands by objections

Lisa Marie Apacible·8 July 2026, 12:56 am

Share

Defense stands by objections

SENATORS Mark Villar, Camille Villar and Joel Villanueva closely examine documentary evidence presented during the impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Duterte at the Senate in Pasay City on Tuesday as the historic proceedings entered another crucial day with prosecutors laying out key evidence before the impeachment court.

AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE

Partner feature

Share

Google Preferred Sources

Get more Daily Tribune stories in your search results

Add Daily Tribune as a preferred source on Google Search.

Add to Google
Partner feature

Suggested Articles

Who is Atty. Sheila Sison?
PAGE THREE

Who is Atty. Sheila Sison?

Virtually unknown outside legal circles before the impeachment trial, lawyer Sheila Sison needed only one appearance…

Alvin Murcia·8 July 2026

Escudero: VP need not appear
PAGE THREE

Escudero: VP need not appear

Senate court presiding officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero on Tuesday rejected the House prosecution panel’s attempt to…

Raffy Ayeng·8 July 2026

Narrative warheats up at Senate
PAGE THREE

Narrative warheats up at Senate

The perception battle was evident in the ongoing trial of Vice President Sara Duterte, particularly with her appearance…

Chito Lozada·8 July 2026

Prosecutors hail trial gains
PAGE THREE

Prosecutors hail trial gains

‘We are very satisfied with the outcome of today’s trial, and we hope to sustain this throughout the 90 trial days. We…

Jerod Orcullo·8 July 2026

Filipino seafarers assured stronger protection
PAGE THREE

Filipino seafarers assured stronger protection

The Department of Migrant Workers (DMW) has pledged to further strengthen the protection and welfare of Filipino…

Neil Alcober·6 July 2026

Focus crimes down 30% in June — PNP
PAGE THREE

Focus crimes down 30% in June — PNP

The Philippine National Police (PNP) on Monday claimed a 30.43-percent drop in focus crimes nationwide in June,…

Jing Villamente·6 July 2026

The defense team of Vice President Sara Duterte on Tuesday defended its string of courtroom objections during the second day of her impeachment trial, saying the interruptions were part of a deliberate legal strategy to protect the Vice President’s rights and preserve issues for the record.

The explanation came after defense counsel Carlo Joaquin Narvasa repeatedly objected to questions from House prosecutors as they presented testimony from National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) senior agent John Mark Calilung, the government’s digital forensics expert tasked with authenticating electronic evidence, including records obtained from Meta Platforms Inc.

Narvasa’s repeated “Objection, Your Honor” became one of the day’s most talked-about moments, with clips of the proceedings quickly circulating on social media and spawning memes comparing the hearing to a courtroom television drama.

Defense spokesperson Michael Poa said many of the reactions stemmed from a misunderstanding of courtroom procedure.

“For example, during direct examination, a lawyer generally cannot ask leading questions — those that can be answered with a simple ‘yes’ or ‘no’ and already suggest the answer,” Poa told reporters after the hearing.

“It’s as if the lawyer is answering the question, giving the testimony, and then merely asking the witness to confirm it,” he explained.

Under the Rules of Court, leading questions are generally prohibited during direct examination because the witness — not the lawyer — is expected to provide the testimony.

Poa stressed that the defense was not objecting merely to disrupt the proceedings but to ensure that any legal issues were properly raised.

“Even if our objections are overruled, that’s fine. What’s important is that our position is placed on the record,” he said.

He added that the defense also sought to challenge the admissibility and authenticity of documentary and electronic evidence presented by the prosecution.

Earlier in the day, the defense unsuccessfully moved to bar Calilung from testifying, arguing that he had not been identified in the original impeachment complaints. Presiding Officer Francis “Chiz” Escudero denied the motion, ruling that witnesses identified during pretrial may testify.

Poa also rejected suggestions that the day’s proceedings should be viewed as victories or defeats for either side.

“When it comes to the defense, we don’t really count wins or losses,” he said.

“We’re only on our first witness and the second day of trial. It’s far too early to look at it that way.”

Instead, he said, the defense’s focus remains on building a complete legal record that could become relevant later in the impeachment proceedings or in any subsequent judicial review.

Asked about possible future motions from the prosecution, Poa declined to speculate.

“There’s room to argue on different issues,” he said. “Once the prosecution files its motion, we will definitely present our position.”

The Senate impeachment court is set to resume hearings as House prosecutors continue presenting evidence in support of the Articles of Impeachment against Duterte, while the defense is expected to maintain its procedural challenges throughout the trial.

Also read

Defense: Objections are trial strategy, not courtroom stunt
NATION

Defense: Objections are trial strategy, not courtroom stunt

The defense team of Vice President Sara Duterte on Tuesday defended its barrage of courtroom objections during the second day of her…

Lisa Marie Apacible·7 July 2026

Also read

Defensor: We're satisfied with day two of impeachment trial
NATION

Defensor: We're satisfied with day two of impeachment trial

House Public Prosecutor Rep. Lorenz Defensor said that their team was quite satisfied with the result of the second day of the impeachment…

Jerod Orcullo·7 July 2026