Community-based vigilance and national security
Philippine maritime territory is roughly seven times larger than its land area, and panelists highlighted the necessity of proactive local participation in reporting and monitoring. Fisherfolk were recognized as frontline responders, providing daily observations on fishing activity, vessel movements, and ecological changes. These efforts complement satellite technology and naval operations, allowing authorities to respond more effectively to incursions and environmental risks.
As of the third quarter of 2025, a total of 78 incidents had been reported in the West Philippine Sea, illustrating the ongoing challenges faced by coastal communities. Satellite mapping revealed significant Chinese presence around strategic locations, including Bajo de Masinloc, Scarborough Shoal, Sabina Shoal, and Kagitingan Reef. Some reefs claimed by the Philippines show fully developed Chinese bases, while vessels are observed circling traditional fishing areas. Satellite tracking using Automatic Identification Systems (AIS) is limited by “dark vessels” turning off their transponders, making community reporting even more vital for real-time situational awareness.
Fisherfolk have faced harassment when attempting to access traditional fishing grounds and have experienced additional hardships from climate-related events and typhoons. Programs such as Fish Right have provided radio communication systems, support in processing official documentation, and satellite offices to ensure safer operations and better coordination with the Philippine Coast Guard. Panelists emphasized the importance of safety, security, and dignity for local communities, alongside strengthening their sense of ownership and role in maritime protection.
Strategic approaches to maritime security
Panel discussions outlined two primary approaches to securing the West Philippine Sea. The first involves diplomatic strategies: asserting Philippine rights through legal frameworks, international law, and coordinated multilateral engagement. This approach emphasizes partnerships, regional cooperation, and the use of scientific and satellite data to inform legal and diplomatic claims.
A contrasting approach, sometimes described as “escalate to deescalate,” focuses on tactical, resource-based responses to maritime challenges. Experts highlighted scenarios in which the temporary withdrawal of foreign vessels during typhoons could provide opportunities for Philippine authorities and fisherfolk to assert control over strategic areas such as Scarborough Shoal. These measures would require robust preparation, fast communication between fleets, and strategic positioning, acknowledging that the Philippines cannot match larger adversaries in direct confrontation but can act decisively in targeted, time-sensitive situations.
Panelists emphasized that both approaches require well-trained, empowered local communities, strong coordination with the Coast Guard, and the development of maritime capacity before material investments. Fisherfolk are considered active participants in enforcement and monitoring rather than armed personnel, providing immediate reporting, ecological observations, and consistent presence in Philippine waters.