Leonen: Congress cannot act as judge or prosecutor in legislative probes



The Department of Justice (DoJ) is seeking P46.44 billion for 2027, slightly higher than its P45.5-billion budget this…

Talking to a powerful neighbor is not necessarily a sign of weakness. Sometimes diplomacy is precisely what a country…

Evidence of credit card hacking cannot be seized under a search warrant that authorizes only the search for illegal…

A judge in a standard court proceeding has to be present in hearings for them to be able to appreciate evidence and…

Quezon City Regional Trial Court Branch 98 on Friday issued a warrant of arrest against Vice President Sara Duterte…
Supreme Court Senior Associate Justice Marvic Leonen has reminded both chambers of Congress to refrain from acting as judge or prosecutor when conducting inquiries in aid of legislation.
Leonen stressed that the Senate and the House of Representatives have no power to determine the guilt of resource persons invited to legislative investigations.
This clarification was issued in a separate concurring opinion to the recent Supreme Court En Banc ruling dismissing petitions filed by pro-Duterte vloggers against the House of Representatives Tri-Committee.
Leonen emphasized that Congress is neither a law enforcement nor a trial agency, and that its investigative power must always be connected to — and in furtherance of — its primary mandate of enacting laws.
“No matter how noble the intentions of the Congress are, they cannot assume the power reposed upon our prosecutorial bodies and courts,” Leonen wrote.
He further underscored that establishing criminal liability is not within the Legislature’s jurisdiction.
“The determination of who is/are liable for a crime or illegal activity, the investigation of the role played by each official, the determination of who should be hailed in court for prosecution and the task of coming up with conclusions and finding of facts regarding anomalies, especially the determination of criminal guilt, are not functions of Congress. It is neither a law enforcement nor a trial agency,” Leonen said.
He added that legislative inquiries must always fall within the bounds of Congress’ constitutional purpose.
“Moreover, it must be related to, and in furtherance of, a legitimate task of Congress,” the Senior Associate Justice noted.