Daily TribuneStephanie Turner made a stand against USA Fencing's transgender policy by refusing to compete against Redmond Sullivan, resulting in her disqualification at the Cherry Blossom Open and sparking widespread debate.
Stephanie Turner takes a knee in protest against competing with transgender athlete Redmond Sullivan at the Cherry Blossom Open.
Photo courtesy of ICONS
Washington, United States — Stephanie Turner, a women’s fencer, sparked controversy when she chose to take a knee instead of competing against transgender athlete Redmond Sullivan at the Cherry Blossom Open, leading to her disqualification and sparking debates over transgender participation in women's sports.
A decision that will undoubtedly echo through sports communities, Stephanie Turner, 31, made the bold choice not to compete against transgender athlete Redmond Sullivan during the Cherry Blossom Open in Maryland last weekend. Turner, who had been competing in four bouts earlier that day, made her stand clear by taking a knee in front of Sullivan, refusing to compete based on USA Fencing’s gender eligibility policy. This moment, captured on video, went viral and sparked a heated discussion on transgender inclusion in women’s sports.
The disqualification, which Turner accepted, came swiftly. Fencing officials issued her a black card — the most severe penalty — and escorted her out of the event. Turner explained her stance, stating, "I am a woman, and this is a man, and this is a women's tournament." She also expressed her belief that USA Fencing had failed to listen to women's objections regarding the current policy, which permits transgender women to compete in women’s events after one year of testosterone suppression treatment.
Martina Navratilova, a retired tennis legend, quickly showed support for Turner, sharing the video of the knee-taking incident on X. In her post, she exclaimed, "This is what happens when female athletes protest! Anyone here still thinks this is fair??? I am fuming… and shame on @USAFencing, shame on you for doing this."
USA Fencing, which introduced its transgender policy in 2023, stated that Turner’s disqualification was not due to her personal stance but because of her refusal to compete against an eligible opponent, in accordance with the International Fencing Federation (FIE) rules. The organization reiterated that it remains committed to inclusivity but respects the need for ongoing dialogue about the matter.
Turner, who has openly discussed the personal toll this decision took on her, acknowledges the potential long-term impact. She is aware of the backlash and potential estrangement from friends, particularly in the LGBTQ+ community, but stands firm in her belief that the policy compromises the integrity of women’s sports.
"I voted red down the ticket this year," Turner said, noting how the debate over transgender inclusion in women’s sports has led her to align with new conservative views. "Something needs to be done."
(Sources: AFP; Jackson Thompson, Fox News; Independent Council on Women’s Sports [ICON]; Martina Navratilova, X)
