The global debate over whaling practices continues to escalate, as two significant developments highlight the growing tensions between conservation efforts and traditional hunting practices. In Greenland, anti-whaling activist Paul Watson remains detained as he faces extradition to Japan, while Iceland has renewed controversial whale-hunting permits through 2029.
Paul Watson’s Legal Battle in Greenland
Paul Watson, founder of Sea Shepherd and prominent environmental activist, has been detained in Greenland since July 2024 following a Japanese arrest warrant. Accused of injuring a Japanese whaler with a stink bomb during a 2010 confrontation at sea, Watson denies the allegations, calling the extradition request politically motivated.
“This is very political. They want their revenge,” Watson said after a Nuuk court extended his detention until 18 December 2024. Despite his legal team providing video evidence disputing the claims, the court has refused to review it.
Watson's lawyers are preparing to appeal the Danish Justice Ministry’s imminent decision on the extradition request, citing concerns about Japan’s judiciary. They argue that extradition would violate Watson's rights, with claims that he could face inhumane treatment in Japanese prisons.
Public and activist support for Watson has grown, with conservationist Jane Goodall urging French President Emmanuel Macron to grant him political asylum. Over 210,000 people have signed a petition demanding his release, and more than 220,000 back his application for French citizenship.
Iceland Resumes Whale Hunting Until 2029
Meanwhile, Iceland has authorized whale hunting for another five years, sparking outrage from animal-rights activists and environmental groups. The permits, announced by the outgoing government on 12 December, allow for the annual capture of 209 fin whales and 217 minke whales during the hunting season from mid-June to September.
This decision follows a turbulent 2023 season, during which whale hunting was temporarily suspended after a government inquiry revealed non-compliance with animal welfare laws. The use of explosive harpoons caused prolonged suffering, with some hunts lasting up to five hours.
Despite criticism, Iceland remains one of only three countries—alongside Norway and Japan—that still permit commercial whaling. Activists, including Iceland’s environment association, have condemned the government’s move as undemocratic and harmful to climate, nature, and animal welfare.
Global Backlash and Continued Activism
Both cases underscore the ongoing conflict between whaling traditions and conservation efforts. Watson’s detention highlights the risks faced by activists challenging powerful nations like Japan, while Iceland’s decision reinforces the resilience of traditional practices despite global opposition.
As the world grapples with balancing cultural heritage, animal welfare, and environmental sustainability, these developments add urgency to the broader conversation about humanity’s role in protecting marine life.