This production succeeds because it is never about showmanship, but a heart-to-heart with the audience. At some point, like Evan, we have all been broken, hoping to be found, trying our best to climb, one branch at a time, and to keep going even when another foothold seems impossible.
Ellis Kirk as Evan Hansen captures the neurotic physicality of a socially anxious, lonely boy. Having caught the sneak peek during the media call before the gala, Sonny Monaghan as Alternate Evan Hansen also sings pitch-perfectly. Meanwhile, Rhys Hopkins as Connor Murphy embodies the troubled, dark side of depression.
The rest of the cast are fully competent: Rebecca McKinnis as Evan’s mom, Heidi; Zoë Athena, Helen Anker and Hal Fowler as the Murphys; Tom Dickerson as Jared Kleinman, and Olivia-Faith Kamau as Alana Beck. And these supporting characters are not mere padding — they serve critical roles in portraying mental health within the family dynamic.
What particularly makes this story layered is how the Murphys cope with Connor’s loss, especially the sister Zoe. The dead Connor may have been loved, but he was not liked. This adds texture to the emotional plane of the story, perfectly expressed in the song “Requiem,” where conflicting emotions surface from each family member — especially when Connor’s death seems to bring relief rather than grief, questions rather than loss.
In an age when the destigmatization of mental health is underway, Dear Evan Hansen is more relevant than ever. It is both triggering and hopeful, accessible and insightful, a theater experience that unifies audiences. It reminds us that even in our darkest moments, we can be seen, heard and found.