Daily Tribune

METRO

Promotions

Joji Alonso · Nov 22, 2026, 11:56 PM

Dear Atty. Peachy,

I have worked for the same company for almost 12 years and have consistently received favorable performance evaluations. Over the years, I have taken on additional responsibilities and have often acted as team lead whenever my supervisor was unavailable.

Last year, a managerial position became vacant. Believing that my experience and track record made me a strong candidate, I applied for the post. To my surprise, the company promoted a much younger employee with significantly less experience.

After the promotion, many of my duties were reassigned, I was excluded from management meetings that I had previously attended, and I was given work that seemed unrelated to my skills and experience. When I asked why I was not selected, I was told that management wanted someone "younger and more dynamic" in the role.

The situation has left me feeling marginalized, and I am now considering resigning. Can an employer lawfully deny a promotion based on age? If the company is intentionally sidelining me, does the law provide any protection?

Nikki

q q q

Dear Nikki,

As a rule, an employee has no vested right to promotion solely by reason of seniority, length of service, or satisfactory performance. The selection of personnel for promotion generally falls within management prerogative, and an employer is ordinarily free to determine who is best qualified for a particular position.

That prerogative, however, must be exercised in good faith and for legitimate business reasons. While an employer may consider factors such as competence, leadership ability, and performance, it may not base employment decisions on unlawful discrimination. Thus, if age was used as a determining factor in the promotion process, the employer should justify its decision on grounds unrelated to age.

More importantly, the legal issue may not be limited to the denial of promotion itself. You allege that after being passed over, significant responsibilities were withdrawn from you, you were excluded from meetings that you previously attended, and you were assigned duties that appear inconsistent with your experience and prior role.

These circumstances raise a question of constructive dismissal. Under established labor jurisprudence, constructive dismissal exists when an employer's actions render continued employment impossible, unreasonable, or unlikely, or when there is a substantial diminution of duties, responsibilities, status, or rank. In determining whether constructive dismissal exists, labor tribunals look beyond formal job titles and examine the actual conditions of employment.

A single denial of promotion will not ordinarily constitute constructive dismissal. However, if the denial was followed by a pattern of conduct effectively reducing your role, marginalizing your position, or making continued employment untenable, the totality of those circumstances may be legally significant.

For this reason, you should avoid resigning impulsively. Instead, preserve documentary evidence of the changes to your duties, reporting structure, meeting participation, and performance evaluations. It may also be prudent to seek written clarification from management regarding the reassignment of your responsibilities and exclusion from functions you previously performed.

Atty. Peachy Selda-Gregorio