NATION
Complexity of stagflation
Market watchers had expected growth to hold flat or improve after the government switched on public infrastructure spending.
Stagflation is once again back in the headlines. Analysts from both local and foreign banks have opined, based on the third-quarter Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth estimates, that we are facing stagflation. Even government experts chimed in, saying we are not yet experiencing stagflation, while acknowledging the need to boost growth.
Back in May 2026, I flagged the possibility of a scenario where the Philippines would experience a moderate form of stagflation. However, when a deal was made between Iran and the US on the Strait of Hormuz in June, the situation got a little better and we saw oil prices correct to levels that reduced the probability of a stagflation scenario. Why have stagflation fears reemerged?
The surprise was the third-quarter GDP release: growth slowed to 2.1 percent, after 2.4 percent in the second quarter and 2.8 percent in the first. Excluding the Covid-19 window, that was the slowest since 2009. Market watchers had expected growth to hold flat or improve after the government switched on public infrastructure spending. Inflation, by contrast, is no surprise: the public tracks it closely because it is reported monthly.
Stagflation is a complex issue because it involves high inflation and unemployment as well as slow, if not contracting, economic growth. It is complex because it presents a conundrum — boosting growth through pump-priming will also boost spending. This drives already high inflation higher, which then requires monetary tightening to slow growth. It becomes this circuitous policy logic trap.
What makes this even more complicated is that both inflation and growth depend on consumers’ and firms’ expectations. In other words, the view of the future of inflation and economic growth affects how consumers and firms behave and make decisions, which can also alter the future of inflation and economic growth — another feedback/circuitous system.
But we need to begin somewhere, and for me the priority policy target is economic growth.
Prolonged weakness in demand means firms will have to hike prices to maintain their profitability or stay in business. To manage inflation, we need to manage firms’ confidence level over demand, which unfortunately is slowing down.
How do you jumpstart an economy? The 2003 sci-fi film The Core, starring Aaron Eckhart, Hilary Swank and Stanley Tucci, posed a similar question to its inner earth adventurers: How do you jump-start a planet?
The earth’s rotating core is slowing down as a side effect of the US military’s testing of a tectonic weapon, and the planet will be destroyed unless a team reaches the inner core and detonates a nuclear weapon to restart the rotation.
Setting aside stagflation’s circuitous policy logic trap for a moment, the movie’s nuclear solution maps onto a massive fiscal pump-priming strategy. But like The Core’s plot, it is not that simple.
The team sized its nuclear payload on an estimate of the core’s density, and that estimate was off the mark. A less dense core meant the payload was not enough. The elegant fix was to use fluid dynamics: explode the weapons in sequence so each explosion compounds the effect of the last.
For the Philippine stagflation analogy, the choice is the same: one big policy intervention or a series of smaller ones.
Following the movie’s crossroads point, the policymakers needs to ask: 1) do we have a large enough intervention payload (or can we afford it); 2) what do we know about the current sentiment and sensitivity of consumers and firms (optimistic-pessimistic); and 3) what were the effects of successive external and economic shocks to the macroeconomy over the past five years? These are the critical questions if we are to avoid stagflation with a direct intervention on aggregate demand.
Typical of good adventure movies, The Core ends positively. The earth is saved, the heroes are honored and the truth is revealed.
If the Philippine economy were a movie, we would like the ending to be similar. Stagflation is avoided, growth resumes, inflation subsides and justice is served.
However, the macroeconomy is not a movie and even if this were the case, we are still its actors as well as its audience. We need to play our parts well and create our own positive ending.