HEADLINES
Court orders VP spokes: Explain
Vice President Sara Duterte’s spokesperson, Salvador Paolo A. Panelo Jr., is standing by his remarks despite a show-cause order issued by the impeachment court on Friday over his criticism of several senator-judges whom he accused of acting like prosecutors.
Panelo said he would comply with the court’s directive but invoked the constitutional guarantees of free speech and the public’s right to criticize government officials. He maintained that his remarks questioning the impartiality of several senator-judges were protected expressions of opinion.
He said he would submit a formal response within the prescribed period upon receiving the order, insisting that his statements were made in good faith and did not interfere with the court.
“I welcome the opportunity to demonstrate that my comments were fair, made in good faith, and did not impede, obstruct, or degrade the administration of justice, and were thus constitutionally protected,” he said in a statement dated 20 November.
Panelo cited the 2012 ruling in Garcia Jr. v. Manrique, which held that courts are not beyond public scrutiny and the power to punish for contempt does not prevent citizens from legitimately criticizing judicial authorities.
He also cited the 8 April 2026 decision in Tolentino v. Heydarian which stressed the need to protect public discussions on matters of public interest and cautioned courts against using their contempt power to suppress critical speech.
A problem
The court’s presiding officer, Sen. Chiz Escudero, issued the order after Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo took offense at Panelo’s remarks made in a media interview on 20 November, explicitly calling Senator-judges Raffy Tulfo, Risa Hontiveros, and Kiko Pangilinan “biased” in the impeachment proceedings.
“I believe there’s a problem here. I mean, you’re the spokesperson of the Vice President, who is now on trial here, and then you’re going to make a comment like that to the senator-judges, the impeachment court. It’s like he doesn’t respect the impeachment court,” Tulfo said at the start of Day 45 of the trial on Friday.
“He might forget that the person on trial here is his own boss, the Vice President, whom he represents as spokesperson,” he added.
Gag not applicable
Escudero, however, indicated that the proper action would be a show-cause order against Panelo because he was not covered by Rule 18, or the sub judice rule, which strictly bars public discussion of the merits of the impeachment case.
The gag order applies only to the rival parties — the defense and the prosecution — and the senator-judges.
“However, given the supplicatory application of the rules of court, particularly Rule 71 on contempt, he may be covered under the authority of this court,” Escudero said.
“Instead of asking him to explain, it will be in the form of a show-cause order,” he added.
Panelo’s criticism of Tulfo, Hontiveros, and Pangilinan stemmed from their pointed questioning of former Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) official Rainer dela Fuente, which he called “improper,” tantamount to an attack on the defense witness’s credibility, and reflecting bias against the VP’s camp.
“My view is that the senator-judges themselves who, for the most part, are supposed to simply listen to both sides, are the very ones trying to undermine the witness’s credibility,” Panelo said.
Panelo even urged Escudero to remind his colleagues to exercise restraint and remain impartial.
Sen. Raffy Tulfo had aggressively challenged Dela Fuente on his qualifications and credibility as a defense witness after he admitted that he did not conduct an in-depth analysis of the forensic report he was supposed to disprove.
That report by the prosecution’s witness, forensic financial analyst Alex Cabrera, covered AMLC records, bank statements, insurance records, and corporate documents linked to Duterte and her husband, lawyer Manases Carpio.
Cabrera’s report alleged, among other things, that Duterte had P817.87 million in unexplained wealth.
On Friday, Tulfo questioned why Panelo, who is not a party to the impeachment proceedings, was publicly commenting on the senator-judges’ conduct.