Daily Tribune

OPINION

Boat on the fence

Constable hid a boat to make a point about a regulation against eyesores, whereas Manila hid its urban decay.

John Henry Dodson · Nov 21, 2026, 1:41 AM

In Seaside, California, as social media accounts had it, Etienne Constable kept his boat in his driveway for years until the city decided that boats and trailers belonged behind a six-foot fence.

Being a law-abiding man, Constable built the fence and then asked his neighbor, the artist Hanif Panni, to paint a life-sized, photorealistic boat across it. From the street, the fence disappeared and the “boat” sat in full view, obeying the ordinance and mocking it at the same time.

Seaside’s acting city manager congratulated Constable with a “high five,” and neighbors with boat notices of their own started asking Panni for murals. This suggests that the most effective way to defy a rule is to follow it flawlessly while throwing humor into the mix.

Across the Pacific, Manila put pictures on fences too. Ahead of the 49th ASEAN Summit, barriers along Diokno Boulevard in Pasay, near the Convention Center, were dressed in tarpaulin reproductions of works by National Artists, among them, Amorsolo, Kiukok, Ocampo, and Joya.

Meanwhile, structures near Tambo Bridge in Parañaque were boarded up, and vendors and street dwellers were cleared from areas around the venues. Church leaders, student groups, and opposition lawmakers noted the idea was to spare visiting dignitaries the view of what lay behind.

Rather testily, Malacañang replied that the clearing was part of security preparations, not mere beautification, and the artworks were not meant to hide poverty, urging critics not to politicize the preparations.

A columnist, Doms Pagliawan, not of this paper, pointed out the irony: painters who spent their careers looking squarely at ordinary Filipino life were drafted to help eyes slide past it.

Vicente Manansala, who painted the barrio and the city with equal tenderness, was among those on display, his work lining a barrier that critics said was meant to keep that very life out of sight. Art that was made to mirror Filipinos as they are was pressed into temporary service to show them, selectively, to the rest of the world.

Here is where the two fences part ways.

Constable’s mural winks, since anyone walking past knows it is a fence and that is its whole charm, whereas the Manila panels were presumably not meant to be noticed as panels, at least not by the guests.

The costs fell unevenly: Constable’s was minimal, while our chief of reporters, Raffy Ayeng, reported that a Baclaran eatery was shut for nearly two weeks, leaving a dozen workers who earn about P500 a day without income, with nobody having thought of giving them even a high five. How about a fist bump?

The delegates have since flown home, and the panels, this Contrarian supposes, will go too.

None of this is new: the 1996 APEC summit saw vendors and informal settlers cleared away. The 2007 ASEAN summit became associated with blue fences, and in the 1970s, Imelda Marcos, whom Donald Trump this week lavished with praise for her family’s “good genes,” spruced up the capital for pageants and papal visits.

Every host tidies up the house for company, and the government’s defenders are right that security matters when world leaders come to town. Still, whether a city is tidying its streets or its guest list, a bishop asked plainly: for whom is this development?

Constable hid a boat to make a point about a regulation against eyesores, whereas Manila hid its urban decay, giving the impression that it cared more for optics than actually solving the problems staring Filipinos in the face.