Daily Tribune

HEADLINES

Tulfo tries ejecting Sara’s expert witness

‘You don’t need to be here’

Edjen Oliquino · Nov 20, 2026, 2:37 AM

FORMER AMLC compliance practitioner Atty. Rainer dela Fuente testifies on the 44th day of Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial on Thursday, following the ASEAN Summit break. — Photograph by Aram Lascano for DAILY TRIBUNE

Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo questioned the need for a particular defense witness in Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial on Thursday after a former Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) investigator challenged the prosecution’s financial findings.

“I’m sorry, Mr. Witness, I don’t have any personal thing against you. But you don’t need to be here to prove it,” Tulfo told Atty. Rainer dela Fuente, who served as an AMLC compliance officer. Tulfo then urged the defense to move on.

“Mr. Presiding Officer, we’ve discussed this many times; the impeachment court has been exempted. So why do we still need his expertise, if that’s what you call him,” he added.

Dela Fuente was presented by defense lawyer Mark Vinluan to challenge the prosecution’s use of AMLC records to establish allegations of unexplained wealth against Duterte.

He testified that corporate earnings could not automatically be attributed to individuals without grounds to pierce the corporate veil.

The witness said only salaries or dividends received corporation’s separate legal personality is properly disregarded.

The lawyer cited fraud and the use of a corporation as an individual’s alter ego as possible grounds, subject to judicial determination and due process.

‘Hypothetical’

The testimony touched on Duterte’s declared investment in GenCorp, formerly Timesquare Bee Foods Corp., which the prosecution’s expert witness, lawyer-accountant Alexander Cabrera, had linked to about P211 million in alleged unexplained wealth based on a 20-percent interest.

GenCorp representative Suzette Balucanag-Punay, however, testified that Duterte held no shares or corporate position from 2022 to 2025, although she received P2.14 million in return of capital from an earlier investment.

The company declared no dividends during the period.

Dela Fuente also said SALN disclosures alone were insufficient to establish wrongdoing, citing the need for further investigation before drawing conclusions about increases in declared wealth.

The defense likewise questioned the allegations involving supposed predicate offenses, with Dela Fuente explaining that money laundering required an underlying unlawful activity.

However, before the trial ended for the day, Dela Fuente admitted that he was mainly speaking hypothetically as he had not gone over the actual AMLC financial documents — “just parts” — used by Cabrera.

Dela Fuente also admitted he had not conducted an in-depth analysis of Cabrera’s forensic report, which covered AMLC records, bank statements, insurance records and corporate documents linked to Duterte and her husband, lawyer Manases Carpio.

He said he was not contesting Cabrera’s findings but examining whether the report complied with the law and proper procedures, adding that he respected the forensic accountant’s professional opinion.

Dela Fuente said he could determine on the spot whether the findings complied with legal requirements, particularly the Anti-Money Laundering Act, despite not having access to the report.

Vinluan admitted the defense had not provided Dela Fuente a copy of Cabrera’s report, saying they intended to confront him with it during the proceedings.

“We will be asking him about the forensic report because we feel that he is the best person to refute the forensic report,” Vinluan said.

Dela Fuente said AMLC documents were highly confidential and subject to strict legal requirements, arguing that their confidentiality remained attached even when shared and that disclosure was subject to rules governing their use.

Go to SC

Senator-judge Francis Pangilinan, however, challenged the defense to bring its objection to the admissibility of AMLC documents to the Supreme Court (SC), rather than repeatedly raising it in the impeachment court.

“We already raised this point previously. If they wish to question the ruling of this court, bring it to the Supreme Court. Do not bring it here,” Pangilinan said.

“We will not object to these questions, but they are on a very short leash, Mr. Presiding Officer,” he added.

The impeachment court had earlier ruled that confidentiality provisions did not override a lawful subpoena for the AMLC records.

Latitude

The prosecution sought the records to establish allegations of unexplained wealth and undeclared assets involving Duterte and Carpio.

The documents included covered and suspicious transaction reports from 2006 to 2025, financial intelligence reports, and investigation records.

A summary presented earlier by AMLC executive director Ronel Buenaventura showed P4.4 billion in covered and suspicious transactions involving the couple.

The records also showed Cale88 Foods Corp., a company linked to Carpio, received P319.32 million in inward remittances from China and Hong Kong.

Meanwhile, Senator-judge Alan Peter Cayetano urged the impeachment court to give the defense sufficient latitude to rebut the allegations, saying the proceedings were also political and public acceptance of the outcome mattered.

Senator-judge Joel Villanueva, however, questioned the usefulness of Dela Fuente’s testimony, saying it would be “useless” because he had not seen Cabrera’s report.

“Still, for you to be an intelligent witness, expert witness that is, you have to study, analyze, do some research on the documents presented to you on which you were asked to give your expert opinion,” Raffy Tulfo chimed in.

Senator-judge Camille Villar defended the witness, arguing Cabrera had also relied on internet research in preparing his forensic report. Villar said Dela Fuente deserved equal opportunity to explain universal accounting and financial principles.

“In fairness to the witness, he admitted that his manifestations are all hypothetical. And therefore, we should be guided accordingly,” Pangilinan countered.

In the same vein, Senator-judge Imee Marcos reminded her colleagues that Lady Justice is blindfolded and that “there is no need to read every document or know the personalities involved, as everyone is equal before the law.”

The prosecution, however, criticized the defense’s presentation of clips from the 2012 impeachment trial of former Chief Justice Renato Corona, calling the move irrelevant and an appeal to sympathy.

The defense is presenting three witnesses on Friday and is expected to present additional witnesses in December, with counsel Michael Poa saying they hope to finish presenting their evidence before the year ends.