Daily Tribune

OPINION

Strike out

Our Supreme Court has likewise recognized that a strike may be lawful even if the alleged unfair labor practice ultimately goes unproven, provided the workers genuinely believed it had occurred and the circumstances reasonably supported that belief.

Dean Nilo Divina · Nov 20, 2026, 2:17 AM

Last week, millions of Spanish workers staged their country’s first general strike in 14 years over soaring housing costs. Days later, protesters opposing US President Donald Trump’s visit clashed with police as they tried to march toward the ASEAN Summit venue in Pasay City.

A Swiss labor dispute raises a narrower question. When does a lawful strike become unlawful? And who decides when workers should return?

In Alonso Radesca and Others v Switzerland (Application No. 38204/19 and two others, 5 November 2026), the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) unanimously held that Switzerland had violated Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects freedom of assembly and association.

In 2012, Providence Hospital withdrew from its collective bargaining agreement (CBA) amid takeover talks. When talks over the CBA failed, employees went on strike and picketed in the hospital car park.

The incoming owner promised to honor the CBA through the end of 2013 and keep all employees. The strikers argued that the terms after expiry were less favorable. When they refused to return to work, the hospital dismissed 22 employees. Four union secretaries were later convicted of trespassing for organizing the picket.

The Swiss Federal Supreme Court upheld the dismissals. In its view, the undertaking to honor the CBA made any further strike action disproportionate and therefore unlawful.

The ECtHR disagreed. Neither the Swiss Constitution nor domestic case law gave workers clear notice that an initially lawful strike could become unlawful because a court later deemed the employer’s concessions sufficient. Workers were left to guess whether staying on the picket line could cost them their jobs.

The ECtHR stressed that unions have primary responsibility for deciding whether to continue a strike. In upholding the dismissals, the Swiss courts had failed to weigh the competing interests and had left the workers without effective protection for exercising their right to strike.

The ECtHR also found that the trespassing convictions over the peaceful picket could discourage legitimate union activity. It awarded€€10,000 to the applicant employees and € 5,000 to the applicant union secretaries, plus €€2,500 in costs and expenses to one applicant.

In the Philippines, the Constitution protects the right to strike in accordance with law. The Labor Code prescribes a notice of strike, a strike vote and advance submission of the voting results.

The applicable cooling-off period depends on the grounds for the strike. Mere participation in a lawful strike is insufficient grounds for dismissal.

Our Supreme Court has likewise recognized that a strike may be lawful even if the alleged unfair labor practice ultimately goes unproven, provided the workers genuinely believed it had occurred and the circumstances reasonably supported that belief.

In hospitals, the striking union must maintain a skeletal workforce to protect patients, particularly in emergencies. The Secretary of Labor and Employment may assume jurisdiction over the dispute, triggering a return to work if the strike is already underway.

These safeguards show how the law can protect patients while giving workers fair notice of their obligations. The right to strike may be regulated, even limited. Workers should be able to know the limits before they put their jobs on the line.

After all, a right whose limits can be known only in hindsight is hardly a right at all.

For more of Dean Nilo Divina’s legal tidbits, please visit www.divinalaw.com. For comments and questions, please send an email to cad@divinalaw.com.