METRO
Financial support
Dear Atty. Angela,
I have a son with my girlfriend of six years. She is always very jealous that she would even message some of my female friends and colleagues to stay away from me even when I don’t do anything. This eventually took a toll on our relationship and we broke up, leaving our son in her custody. Since I lost my job due to retrenchment, I could barely give her monthly support for our child but I do my best to provide whatever I have. She claims that I prioritize other women instead of my son. To my shock, she filed a complaint for violation of Section 5(i) of Republic Act 9262 or the Anti-Violence Against Women and Their Children Act of 2004 claiming that I maliciously and willfully refused to extend financial support. Will I be criminally held liable for this?
Siso
□□□□□
Dear Siso,
The mere failure or inability to provide financial support does not automatically amount to a criminal violation under the RA 9262. This law penalizes psychological abuse resulting in mental or emotional suffering which based on the fact you provided, are not present.
In the case of XXX v People, G.R. No. 273288 (4 August 2025), the Supreme Court explained that to convict a person for psychological violence under Section 5(i) of the Anti-VAWC Act, the prosecution must show that: (1) the victim is a woman and/or her child; (2) the woman is the offender’s wife or partner, or someone with whom the offender has a common child; (3) the offender refused to give financial support due; and (4) the refusal was intended to cause mental or emotional suffering.
In this case, the Court acquitted the father who was not able to give financial support to the child. It was ruled that the prosecution failed to prove all the elements of psychological abuse on the ground of failure to give financial support, specifically the intent to inflict mental and emotional anguish by deliberately denying his child of financial support.
The Court stated that while it does not discount the emotional and financial hardship that [the complainant] went through, this does not, by itself, amount to psychological violence as defined under the law and jurisprudence.
Absent any deliberate intent to inflict mental and emotional anguish by willfully denying the child financial support, the proper remedy is civil in nature which is the filing of a case for support against the delinquent parent, under the Civil Code, instead of pursuing a criminal case.
Atty. Angela Antonio