Daily Tribune

BUSINESS

What’s in a (brand) name?

DT · Nov 18, 2026, 1:39 AM

A dominant Metro Manila auto parts importer has lost a nine-year fight to register its brand. The Supreme Court ruled against it, Nosy Tarsee was told. The importer argued that the word had lost its distinctiveness because many registered marks use it. The Court did not accept that. It said the Intellectual Property Office’s findings deserve great respect.

In a decision promulgated on 28 January 2026, the Court en banc denied the company’s trademark application. It held that the mark was confusingly similar to two earlier ones, one registered to an individual and the other filed by a tire manufacturer. The ruling was unanimous.

Nosy Tarsee heard the company was warned earlier. An examiner at the Intellectual Property Office (IPO) rejected the application in 2017. The Bureau of Trademarks upheld the rejection in 2020. The Office of the Director General did the same in 2022. The Court of Appeals followed in 2023. The importer kept appealing anyway.

“They added a stylized font and a descriptive word,” a trademark lawyer told Nosy Tarsee. “The Court saw right through both.” The Court applied the Dominancy Test. It looked at the mark’s most prominent feature, not the small differences around it. The Court found that the same word dominated all three marks.

A colored rectangle around the word in one of them made no real difference. The added word merely described the goods, so it could not distinguish the mark. Nobody can monopolize a generic term.

The Court also found the goods were related. The importer sells suspension, cooling and drivetrain components. The earlier marks covered engine and transmission parts and tires. All are automotive parts, sold through the same channels to the same buyers. The Court said ordinary purchasers would likely assume they came from one source.

The ruling also clarified an earlier decision that required substantial evidence to prove the likelihood of confusion. That standard applies when private parties oppose a mark, the Court said.