Daily Tribune

NATION

SC declares bond requirement, legal fee restrictions for seafarers unconstitutional

Jeffrey G. Damicog · Nov 16, 2026, 10:16 PM

The Supreme Court (SC) has drawn praise on Monday, November 16, after declaring several provisions of the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers and its implementing rules and regulations (IRR) unconstitutional.

“Tagumpay ito ng mga manggagawa, lalo na ng marinong umuwing may pinsala at ng pamilyang naghihintay ng pambili ng gamot,” said Federation of Free Workers (FFW) president Sonny Matula.

(This is a victory for workers, especially seafarers who return home with disabilities and families waiting for money to buy medicines.)

The SC announced on Monday that it had decided on consolidated petitions filed by various parties, including one filed by Matula, challenging the constitutionality of several provisions of Republic Act (RA) No. 12021, or the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers.

Among the provisions struck down was Section 59, which the SC declared unconstitutional and void. The provision required seafarers to post a bond before they could claim monetary awards won in labor cases against their employers while the cases were under court review.

“Ang employer ang umapela, pero ang marinong nanalo ang kailangang maghanap ng pambayad sa piyansa,” Matula said, referring to Section 59.

(The employer filed the appeal, but the seafarer who won the case was the one required to find money to pay for the bond.)

“Bakit kailangan pang mangutang para masingil ang halagang naipanalo mo na?” the lawyer asked.

(Why should seafarers have to borrow money just to claim the monetary awards they have already won?)

The SC also declared Section 60 of RA 12021 unconstitutional and void. The provision imposed restrictions on seafarers' choice of legal representation, including a 10% cap on lawyers' fees based on the successful outcome of a case.

The petitioners argued that the provision encroached on the SC's constitutionally mandated authority to regulate the legal profession.

“Sa simula pa lang, tiwala na akong kapag lumampas ang Kongreso sa hangganang iyon, idedeklarang walang bisa ng Korte Suprema ang probisyong labag sa Konstitusyon,” Matula said.

(From the beginning, I was confident that the Supreme Court would strike down the provision if Congress overstepped its constitutional boundaries.)