OPINION
Coming up short
After weeks of preparation, losing your first witness and rescheduling your next hardly inspires confidence.
After months of waiting to hear Vice President Sara Duterte’s side, the defense finally called its witnesses last week. Well, six of them anyway. And what a week it was.
It began awkwardly. Former law dean Ralph Sarmiento, originally listed as the opening witness, publicly declined, saying he wanted to preserve his independence. Then corporate counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay had to postpone her scheduled appearance for medical reasons.
Both had perfectly understandable excuses. Still, after weeks of preparation, losing your first witness and rescheduling your next hardly inspired confidence.
Then the actual testimonies began.
Davao City assessor Jaime Adalin tried to establish that a property in Mans Carpio’s name was already reflected in Duterte’s SALN. But under questioning, he could not conclusively identify the property covered by the title as the one that was declared.
Next, Samal City assessor John Kenneth Enumerables encountered a similar problem with another property. He relied on matching assessed values, while conceding that he could not definitively establish that the SALN entry referred to the same lot.
Then Davao City accountant Vingelin Bajan offered a more concrete explanation: a payment Duterte received in 2023 was a salary differential from her earlier service as mayor, not compensation for her work as Vice President.
That was a point worth examining. But Bajan’s difficulty in recalling other details did little to strengthen the defense’s overall presentation.
Balucanag-Punay, finally on the stand, described Duterte’s supposed “loose investment” in a Jollibee franchise, which generated P2.14 million in payments. Unfortunately, she could not produce a written agreement or establish the original investment amount. Even presiding officer Chiz Escudero had questions.
Thursday brought lawyer Anel Martin Antero and Chadrin Parian to explain a P205,000 Tokyo dinner and a P256,000 purchase of shoes, respectively, using Carpio’s credit card. Explanations were given, but supporting proof was thin.
Throughout the week, several senator-judges expressed frustration over evasive answers and faulty recollections. Escudero rightly reminded everyone that an unsatisfactory answer was not automatically contemptuous. Still, the discomfort in the courtroom was not hard to miss.
On Thursday, Pia Cayetano and Robin Padilla seemed more interested in sparring with the prosecution. Cayetano objected to questions about the basketball team’s shoes; Padilla wondered why an assessor’s trip to China mattered, to which prosecutors countered that they were testing his credibility. To some viewers, it looked suspiciously like an attempt to distract from the defense’s shortcomings.
The more consequential question, of course, is whether any of this comes close to answering the larger allegations about cash, bank deposits, investments and other supposedly undeclared wealth. So far, it does not.
Perhaps the most curious development was the dropping by the defense of 15 bank officers from its witness list, followed by a sixteenth the next day. Counsel said their testimony was unnecessary, including that of a BPI official who had acknowledged writing a relevant letter.
Maybe. But dropping every planned bank witness in a case built largely on financial records certainly raises eyebrows.
None of this means the defense has lost. It still has opportunities to challenge the prosecution’s analysis. And there are the senator-judges who must evaluate the evidence fairly. But its first week did little to dent Alexander Cabrera’s estimate of P817.87 million in allegedly undeclared assets and income of Duterte and Carpio.
After months of preparation, the defense has offered fragments of explanations, not a convincing answer to the central question.
Perhaps that answer is coming. Who knows? But it certainly wasn’t there last week.